29 October 2026                                Business Spotlight  |  Editorial Extra  |  News  |  Podcasts  |  About us  |  Home

Industry Guide


Archive




2012-09-02 VIR-002

Virgin Rail Group

Virgin Trains: Concerns were expressed on West Coast Bid process over three years


keywords: click to search

Stagecoach Group plc
Virgin Rail Group
Virgin Trains
West Coast Main Line
WCML
*WCML2012
franchises
franchising




Words in [single square brackets] included hyperlinks in the original document

Words in [[double square brackets]] are editorial additions or corrections

Words in [[[triple square brackets]]] indicate embedded images or graphics in the original document. (These are not usually archived unless they contain significant additional information.)




< operators’ contracts index





Press release


Virgin Rail Group

Virgin Trains: Concerns were expressed on West Coast Bid process over three years


  date 2 September 2012
  source Virgin Rail Group
  type Press release

Despite the Department for Transport(DfT) and Transport Minister, Justine Greening claiming that Virgin only started challenging the process once they had lost the Bid for the West Coast rail franchise, records show this not to be the case,

Tony Collins, Cheif Executive Officer for Virgin Rail Group said today: 'There must be some misunderstanding at DfT. We have had several meetings over the last two or three years where we have expressed our concerns over the bid process, how it evaluates the bids and how it leads to the sorts of failures we have seen on EC with NatEx and GNER. We certainly have dates of meetings, follow-up letters and obviously our notes of what was discussed."

Sir Richard Branson, Founder of Virgin Group is also on record as saying “We have to ask: do we want winning franchise bids based just on the bottom line, or do we want innovative ideas taken into account?” Sir Richard asked. “We want it to be a beauty parade based on innovation and quality and service. Cheap trains, cheap seats, cheap staff, cheap service. That’s not what people want.”

“If bids are won and lost on purely the bottom line, we will get the situation where we lost out on East Coast Main Line to someone overbidding,” Sir Richard continued, “East Coast could have been transformed but, under the antiquated bidding system, it went to the highest bidder and you can see the mess that took place.”


Railnews Archive ::: 2012-09-02 VIR-002








related documents



2012-08-15 New operator for West Coast rail passengers (DfT Department for Transport)

2012-08-15 Press Statement: from Sir Richard Branson, Founder Virgin Group (Virgin Rail Group)

2012-08-15 FirstGroup welcomes award of Intercity West Coast rail franchise (FirstGroup plc)